Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.
Your Opinion/Questions
Source: Cubicle Guy
Published: December 18, 2001 Author: Cubicle Guy
Posted on 12/18/01 2:08 PM Pacific by CubicleGuy
On Saturday, an employee of the Sacramento Bee (a "liberal" newspaper) was invited to speak during the commencement program for the graduating students at California State University in Sacramento. Before she was able to complete her speech, the crowd in attendance shouted her down, perceiving her message as a liberal whine about the way the Bush administration has chosen to conduct the war on terrorism. A review of the entire contents of the speech reveals that the true main message of the text was a call to the students, as the future leaders and citizens of the United States, to protect the rights enumerated in the Constitution and Bill of Rights, particularly the right to a free press, in order that government corruption and the restrictions on rights might not go unreported to the American people.
It would seem that the majority of those participating in the discussion of this event stand behind the rights of the students to respond to the speaker by shouting her down. In other words, censorship is seen to be a valuable tool in protecting the rights of U.S. citizens to not be offended or be made uncomfortable by what someone else may have to say, whether the perception of what is being said is correct or not.
Given the evident public sentiment, I propose that FreeRepublic.com should adapt to the demands of an ever-increasingly informed citizenry by doing the following:
By adopting these new measures, and by the free distribution of these capabilities to all who participate here, surely this will eliminate the possibility of giving offense to anyone who might otherwise misunderstand a communication by their fellow travelers, and will (in the view of many) promote the cause of freedom, liberty and justice for all, and make FreeRepublic a much more influential voice and force for good in the United States of America, and, indeed, the world.
What do you say, JimRob? Surely, you can see the obvious value in this suggestion. It's what the informed majority evidently need and want.
I must say that I'm excited and looking forward to the future version of
FreeRepublic, which will be a vast improvement over the current limitations
imposed (benevolently, of course!) by you, our beloved moderator.
1 posted on 12/18/01 2:08 PM Pacific by
CubicleGuy
[ Post
Reply | Private Reply | View
Replies | Report
Abuse ]
FR is not a democracy, any more than your house is a democracy.
JimRob owns it, and sets the rules.
Your lame attempt at an analogy falls flat.
2 posted on 12/18/01 2:14 PM Pacific by
sinkspur
[ Post
Reply | Private Reply | To
1 | View
Replies | Report
Abuse ]
Ho Hum. Nobody cares about your whining rant.
3 posted on 12/18/01 2:14 PM Pacific by
Rodney King
[ Post
Reply | Private Reply | To
1 | View
Replies | Report
Abuse ]
Are you STILL here?
4 posted on 12/18/01 2:17 PM Pacific by
tet68
[ Post
Reply | Private Reply | To
1 | View
Replies | Report
Abuse ]
Hmmmmm.Things slow up in Harlem?
5 posted on 12/18/01 2:18 PM Pacific by
tet68
[ Post
Reply | Private Reply | To
1 | View
Replies | Report
Abuse ]
One small aside, I think she was much higher up the food chain than "an employee" of the Bee.
Good luck to ya. We seem to be caught in a cyclical argument. liberals are
bad when they shout conservatives down, so we should shout them down in return.
I read the other threads and it seems we easilly justify acting like
lioberals.
6 posted on 12/18/01 2:18 PM Pacific by
breakem
[ Post
Reply | Private Reply | To
1 | View
Replies | Report
Abuse ]
Hey, it's your website. Straighten this guy out, will ya'?
7 posted on 12/18/01 2:18 PM Pacific by
RedBloodedAmerican
[ Post
Reply | Private Reply | To
1 | View
Replies | Report
Abuse ]
Dude, this would have been a wise use of FReepmail.
8 posted on 12/18/01 2:19 PM Pacific by
RedBloodedAmerican
[ Post
Reply | Private Reply | To
1 | View
Replies | Report
Abuse ]
Why should an elite few be able to decide what the rest of us should be permitted to read here? This is obviously un-democratic.
We don't live in a democracy, but a republic. And this site is called Free
REPUBLIC
9 posted on 12/18/01 2:21 PM Pacific by
Darth Dan
[ Post
Reply | Private Reply | To
1 | View
Replies | Report
Abuse ]
You're right. She had every right to tell the graduates that the Osama tape was probably a government fake, and they should have politely applauded her.
GET REAL.
10 posted on 12/18/01 2:24 PM Pacific by
Dog Gone
[ Post
Reply | Private Reply | To
1 | View
Replies | Report
Abuse ]
There are many reasons why one might celebrate the comeuppance of a righteous
controlling twit.
Sermonizing as a means to intimidate has a time and place.
This sad excuse for a business person chose the wrong time and place, And
incidentally...
You are one pompous ass.
11 posted on 12/18/01 2:25 PM Pacific by
Publius6961
[ Post
Reply | Private Reply | To
1 | View
Replies | Report
Abuse ]
I don't know what you're on, but could you pass it around?
12 posted on 12/18/01 2:25 PM Pacific by
TomServo
[ Post
Reply | Private Reply | To
1 | View
Replies | Report
Abuse ]
Too snippy for a guy rant. JMO.
13 posted on 12/18/01 2:25 PM Pacific by
Stentor
[ Post
Reply | Private Reply | To
1 | View
Replies | Report
Abuse ]
the ability to delete entire threads should also be granted to every participant, posters and lurkers alike.
Hmm. Too bad I can't try it out.
14 posted on 12/18/01 2:27 PM Pacific by
Dan Nunn
[ Post
Reply | Private Reply | To
1 | View
Replies | Report
Abuse ]
You all wrap yourselves in the American flag and claim to be fighting for freedom and the U.S. constitution.
I think a lot of you may not be very sincere, and I think some of you are probably outright hypocrites.
15 posted on 12/18/01 2:27 PM Pacific by
fightforfreedom
[ Post
Reply | Private Reply | To
1 | View
Replies | Report
Abuse ]
I, for one, appreciated your ironic post. Perhaps you need to put one of
those </irony> thingies at the end for the many literalists attending
today.
16 posted on 12/18/01 2:28 PM Pacific by
AZLiberty
[ Post
Reply | Private Reply | To
1 | View
Replies | Report
Abuse ]
Start your own board.
17 posted on 12/18/01 2:28 PM Pacific by
Dan from Michigan
[ Post
Reply | Private Reply | To
1 | View
Replies | Report
Abuse ]
This ain't my website. It Jim Robinson's website.
I just visit.
18 posted on 12/18/01 2:28 PM Pacific by
Lazamataz
[ Post
Reply | Private Reply | To
7 | View
Replies | Report
Abuse ]
I was referring to your FR Fundraiser thread last summer...something about
how you would run the website... :)
19 posted on 12/18/01 2:31 PM Pacific by
RedBloodedAmerican
[ Post
Reply | Private Reply | To
18 | View
Replies | Report
Abuse ]
You don't like it 'round here? Get lost. You like the lady from the Bee?
Don't read it much, do ya? I did for years. I've also been around here for
years. Your mewling is pitiful.
20 posted on 12/18/01 2:32 PM Pacific by
RightOnline
[ Post
Reply | Private Reply | To
1 | View
Replies | Report
Abuse ]
Midol.
Works wonders for those days when you have cramps.
Listen, I'm the first one that jumped down the Moderators s**t when I felt they were too heavyhanded. But they make a good point: There will be people who bitch no matter what. If they police too much, they will be bitched at. If they police too little, then you have the "Britanny Spears/Severed Penis/What's Your Favorite Music CD" threads dominating the board.
I told them that, when you are bitched at equally by the Puritans and the
Libertines, then you know you are at balance.
21 posted on 12/18/01 2:33 PM Pacific by
Lazamataz
[ Post
Reply | Private Reply | To
1 | View
Replies | Report
Abuse ]
I was referring to your FR Fundraiser thread last summer...something about how you would run the website... :)
I'd run it into the ground. ;^)
Nah -- on second thought, I'd hire JimRob, then things would run okay. ;^)
22 posted on 12/18/01 2:34 PM Pacific by
Lazamataz
[ Post
Reply | Private Reply | To
19 | View
Replies | Report
Abuse ]
Your agruments are based on a false premise.
Yes, you have a right to
free speech. However, FR is a private endeavor (like many web/internet forums)
and as such, does not have to be the forum for you to express your free speech
rights. It just happens that FR (like many web/internet forums) allows people to
post.
Being a private endeavor gives FR the right to censor. If you feel
that infringes on your free speech rights, you have the right to establish your
own web forum from which you may speak.
Posting in forums, such as FR are
privileges, not rights. FR does have the right to restrict your (or anyone
else's) postings here--because FR is a private endeavour. That does not restrict
your free speech--it only restricts it in this forum--which FR has a
right to do.
23 posted on 12/18/01 2:35 PM Pacific by
TomGuy
[ Post
Reply | Private Reply | To
1 | View
Replies | Report
Abuse ]
fightforfreedom - member since - December 18th, 2001
Duration at FR: 0 days.
24 posted on 12/18/01 2:37 PM Pacific by
VRWCmember
[ Post
Reply | Private Reply | To
15 | View
Replies | Report
Abuse ]
i love FR just the way it is (to paraphrase the billy joel tune). why fix
something if it isn't broken?
25 posted on 12/18/01 2:37 PM Pacific by
contessa machiaveli
[ Post
Reply | Private Reply | To
1 | View
Replies | Report
Abuse ]
If I was invited to give a commencement speech at a historically black college, and started droning on about the benefits of Apartheid, and they shouted me down, would you consider it a dark day for democracy? What if I was invited to Brandeis and started screaming "Heil Hitler" into the microphone?
This lady was invited to CSU Sacramento to give a commencement speech. She basically said all of the students who supported the president were too ignorant to see what was going on in America, and that they were all lazy fascists who didn't care if their rights were stripped away. She accused them of being racists for supporting racial profiling. The students didn't like this, so they booed her. Get over it.
It's not like they shouted her down when she was at a political rally. They
didn't steal copies of her newspaper and burn them. They didn't threaten to
physically attack her.
26 posted on 12/18/01 2:38 PM Pacific by
xm177e2
[ Post
Reply | Private Reply | To
1 | View
Replies | Report
Abuse ]
Britney Spears did NOT sever my penis. I swear.
27 posted on 12/18/01 2:39 PM Pacific by
one_particular_harbour
[ Post
Reply | Private Reply | To
21 | View
Replies | Report
Abuse ]
Britney Spears did NOT sever my penis. I swear.
28 posted on 12/18/01 2:39 PM Pacific by
one_particular_harbour
[ Post
Reply | Private Reply | To
21 | View
Replies | Report
Abuse ]
why fix something if it isn't broken?
I did that with my
keyboard last week--cleaned it.
I don't like this new keyboard.
29 posted on 12/18/01 2:40 PM Pacific by
TomGuy
[ Post
Reply | Private Reply | To
25 | View
Replies | Report
Abuse ]
If your post was an attempt at humor by parodying liberal whiners, you came
across a little too genuine. If however, you were serious, then you really are a
strange and sad little man.
30 posted on 12/18/01 2:41 PM Pacific by
VRWCmember
[ Post
Reply | Private Reply | To
1 | View
Replies | Report
Abuse ]
I, for one, appreciated your ironic post. Perhaps you need to put one of those thingies at the end for the many literalists attending today.
Right, AZ.
The post was obviously an irony along the lines of Jonathan Swift's A Modest Proposal. But most of the people who replied just didn't get it.
What does this say about the average IQ around here?
31 posted on 12/18/01 2:42 PM Pacific by
codeword
[ Post
Reply | Private Reply | To
16 | View
Replies | Report
Abuse ]
How long do you think 'fightforfreedom' (post #15) will last?
32 posted on 12/18/01 2:43 PM Pacific by
VRWCmember
[ Post
Reply | Private Reply | To
28 | View
Replies | Report
Abuse ]
I read the other threads and it seems we easilly justify acting like lioberals.
That is because,while we might not like it,we extend civil liberties to
liberals(Who rant and shout conservatives down.)They however,(as evidenced by
CG)do not feel they have to extend those same liberties to us.
33 posted on 12/18/01 2:44 PM Pacific by
tet68
[ Post
Reply | Private Reply | To
6 | View
Replies | Report
Abuse ]
What in the world are you talking about?
34 posted on 12/18/01 2:44 PM Pacific by
Saundra Duffy
[ Post
Reply | Private Reply | To
1 | View
Replies | Report
Abuse ]
I want Moose and Cheese emoticons.
35 posted on 12/18/01 2:45 PM Pacific by
IowaHawk
[ Post
Reply | Private Reply | View
Replies | Report
Abuse ]
Where in the 1st Amendment (or The Constitution, for that matter) does it say
that we have the right to polite free speech, all other speech banned?
36 posted on 12/18/01 2:45 PM Pacific by
randog
[ Post
Reply | Private Reply | To
1 | View
Replies | Report
Abuse ]
I would like the ability to ignore what is said by certain posters. Kind of like a personal black list button. It would only apply to what I see when visiting FR not what anyone else can see.
For example, I no longer have any interest in reading any of the posts of the people that condoned or cheered at the burning of St. John The Divine Cathedral. For example, Kevin Curry and many others. Some posters even lamented that certain priests that they hated didn't get scorched. There are some real nutters that post here.
Recently there have been a lot of people that seem barely literate. I don't want to have to wade through all that gibberish to find interesting replies. It's gotten to the point where I'll often just read the recent articles one after another without even looking at a single reply, simply because I don't feel like reading 100 insipid posts to find 5 interesting ones.
A personal black list button would be great.
37 posted on 12/18/01 2:45 PM Pacific by
wooly_mammoth
[ Post
Reply | Private Reply | To
1 | View
Replies | Report
Abuse ]
I have heard people on radio shows who were there stated many times it had
nothing to do with her being a liberal and more to the fact that they felt like
she was spoiling their day. It was supposted to be about their lives and what
they accomplished at college. All of those who have called both the liberal and
conservative radio shows that I have listened to stated that.
38 posted on 12/18/01 2:46 PM Pacific by
Libertarian_4_eva
[ Post
Reply | Private Reply | To
6 | View
Replies | Report
Abuse ]
Thank God somebody gets it.
To the rest of you: thanks for proving my point.
39 posted on 12/18/01 2:46 PM Pacific by
CubicleGuy
[ Post
Reply | Private Reply | To
16 | View
Replies | Report
Abuse ]
This, too, is just in keeping with the invaluable principles of
democracy
I don't want this site to be about democracy. This site is
about a FREE REPUBLIC. Go to hell Anti-War liberal dirtbag hippie scum.
40 posted on 12/18/01 2:47 PM Pacific by
Libertarian_4_eva
[ Post
Reply | Private Reply | To
1 | View
Replies | Report
Abuse ]
Your lame attempt at an analogy falls flat.
If that post was not dripping with irony, I will eat my keyboard. Mr. Sink, I
believe you have been had.
41 posted on 12/18/01 2:47 PM Pacific by
don-o
[ Post
Reply | Private Reply | To
2 | View
Replies | Report
Abuse ]
CubicleGuy, ask your boss for a window seat. You need some fresh air. Rush
Limbaugh spoke at Humboldt State in the late 80s on one of his two "Rush to
Excellence" tour of the North Coast and the socialist professors and agitators
went nuts. The show went on any way to a packed house. I am quite proud to have
been one of the Sponsors of his two appearances here. Now the tide is turning
and it is about time. Jim Robinson can do any thing he wants here. It's his
site.
42 posted on 12/18/01 2:48 PM Pacific by
tubebender
[ Post
Reply | Private Reply | To
1 | View
Replies | Report
Abuse ]
Makes me wonder if some posters think "irony" means your clothes look
smoothed out
43 posted on 12/18/01 2:49 PM Pacific by
Freeper john
[ Post
Reply | Private Reply | To
16 | View
Replies | Report
Abuse ]
Who cares?
44 posted on 12/18/01 2:50 PM Pacific by
one_particular_harbour
[ Post
Reply | Private Reply | To
15 | View
Replies | Report
Abuse ]
What does this say about the average IQ around here?
It ain't complementary, that's for sure.
45 posted on 12/18/01 2:51 PM Pacific by
CubicleGuy
[ Post
Reply | Private Reply | To
31 | View
Replies | Report
Abuse ]
My comment was directed to those ho said the liberals shout and hoot our speakers so it's okay to shout theirs.
I do believe the views she espoused are liberal and the fact that she is a big deal at the bee further supports that contention.
As for why people were hooting, I support the stand and turn the back
silently method.
46 posted on 12/18/01 2:51 PM Pacific by
breakem
[ Post
Reply | Private Reply | To
38 | View
Replies | Report
Abuse ]
Duration at FR: 0 days
Of course.
But don't kid
yourselves that you are proponents of freedom and defenders of the U.S.
constitution.
You don't represent America and God is not on your side if
you are against freedom of speech and the right to protest against those whom
govern.
Such individuals are authoritarian and more characteristic of
the types whom are appreciated in the Communist East.
Many of you would
simply like everyone here to tout the Party Line.
That's most
sad...
I know not what course others may take, but as for
me, give me liberty or give me death. - Patrick Henry
47 posted on 12/18/01 2:52 PM Pacific by
fightforfreedom
[ Post
Reply | Private Reply | To
24 | View
Replies | Report
Abuse ]
I agree, but no excuse to act like them. I prefer the silent stand and turn
technique.
48 posted on 12/18/01 2:52 PM Pacific by
breakem
[ Post
Reply | Private Reply | To
33 | View
Replies | Report
Abuse ]
Who cares?
God. And believe me....He's watching...
49 posted on 12/18/01 2:53 PM Pacific by
fightforfreedom
[ Post
Reply | Private Reply | To
44 | View
Replies | Report
Abuse ]
liberals are bad when they shout conservatives down, so we should shout them down in return. I read the other threads and it seems we easily justify acting like liberals.
There is a difference. Liberals have their little brown shirt groups which
plan the disruption of conservative speech at colleges across the nation. This
was a spontaneous outpouring by students, many of whom, I suspect, would not
even describe themselves as conservatives. I not advocate the right create
groups such as the Mumia crowd to shout people down. But I don't have a problem
with an audience turning on a speaker.
50 posted on 12/18/01 2:54 PM Pacific by
LarryLied
[ Post
Reply | Private Reply | To
6 | View
Replies | Report
Abuse ]
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.
[ Threads | Comments | Self-Search | Search | Topics
/ Post | Bookmark | Abuse | Settings | Help! ]
| Spirit Of Truth Page | Stock Market Update |